Телеграм канал «Ecce Verbum»

Notes

Christian Apologetics – On Worldviews, Visions, and Philosophical Dialogue

§ 1. On Worldviews

  1. What is a worldview? – It is the set of fundamental assumptions by which a person interprets reality; truth; morality; human beings; society; knowledge; and the purpose of life.

  2. Every person has a worldview – Everyone has one, even if implicitly. Even those who have never studied philosophy usually have basic ideas about: good and evil; truth; freedom; the meaning of existence.

  3. Worldview is not the same as religion – Not exactly, because a religion usually contains a worldview, but there are secular, philosophical, political, and cultural worldviews.

  4. Why Apologetics needs to understand worldviews – Because religious debates often involve deeper differences than simple isolated opinions.  People may disagree about the nature of reality; the possibility of truth; the existence of God; the meaning of morality.

§ 2. On Assumptions

  5. What are assumptions? – They are fundamental ideas assumed before many lines of reasoning. Examples: trust in reason; the existence of the external world; the validity of logic; moral objectivity.

  6. Is there such a thing as completely neutral thought – Many philosophers argue that it is not entirely so. Everyone interprets facts based on language; culture; experiences; philosophical assumptions.

  7. Does recognizing assumptions destroy objectivity – Not necessarily. It only means recognizing human limitations; the need for critical reflection; the importance of intellectual honesty.

§ 3. On Christian Worldview

  8. What are the central elements of the Christian worldview – Traditionally, God as the foundation of reality; rational creation; human dignity; moral objectivity; human fall; redemption; transcendent purpose.

  9. Does Christianity see the universe as meaningless – No. The Christian tradition maintains that reality possesses intelligibility; history has purpose; human existence has meaning.

  10. Does Christianity consider truth objective – Yes. The classical tradition affirms truth exists independently of subjective preferences.

§ 4. On Materialism

  11. What characterizes a materialist worldview – The idea that only matter and physical processes fundamentally exist.

  12. Does materialism influence morality – Frequently, yes. Depending on the form adopted, it can affect the concept of person; freedom; Consciousness; Dignity; Ethics.

  13. Why does Christianity criticize materialism – Because it considers it insufficient to reduce the human being to: physicochemical processes; biology; impersonal matter.

§ 5. About Naturalism

  14. What characterizes a naturalist worldview – The idea that all reality can be explained exclusively by natural causes.

  15. Does Naturalism eliminate transcendence – Generally, yes. It tends to reject miracles; revelation; supernatural reality.

  16. Can Christianity engage in dialogue with naturalists – Yes. Many discussions involve metaphysics; epistemology; morality; philosophy of mind; origin of the universe.

§ 6. On Relativism

  17. What is relativism?

It is the position according to which truth or morality depends entirely on culture; the individual; context.

  18. Why do apologists criticize radical relativism – Because it can generate difficulties such as self-contradiction; impossibility of objective moral criticism; dissolution of universal truth.

  19. Does Christianity admit cultural diversity – Yes. But it distinguishes legitimate cultural diversity; absolute denial of objective truth.

§ 7. On Nihilism

  20. What is a nihilistic worldview – It is the view according to which there is no objective meaning; absolute values ​​do not exist; life lacks transcendent purpose.

  21. How does Christianity respond to nihilism – Affirming intelligibility of being; value of the person; reality of good; transcendent hope.

🔗2/2

#philosophy

Pentecost: The Birth of the Church of Christ

Traditionally, we distinguish three stages in the establishment of the Church by Christ:

1. Preparing the Church during the time of Jesus Christ's public activity on earth. The teaching of our Lord forms the deposit of faith of the Church.

2. Completing this preparation through the sacrifice of the Son of God on the cross, from which all Sacraments draw their power, being the spiritual good of the Church.

3. Beginning the public activity of the Church after the descent of the Holy Spirit upon the Apostles, who helps them and their successors in carrying out the mission of the Church throughout the earth. The Day of Pentecost should therefore be regarded as the proper birth of the Church for the world.

"The Church, having already been conceived, was born from the side of the second Adam on the cross, and first appeared to men on the great day of Pentecost. On that day the Holy Spirit began to manifest His gifts in the mystical body of Christ." Leo XIII, Divinum Illud Munus

#holyspirit

The Ascension of the Lord

It is a dogma of the Catholic faith that our Lord, Jesus Christ, ascended into heaven, body and soul, on the 40th day after His glorious Resurrection. This truth can be understood christologically as well as soteriologically.

Christology

The Ascension reveals to us the divine power of Christ, which was the primary efficient cause of His Ascension. For Christ did not ascend by His human power (hence the evangelist Mark writes of being "taken up into heaven"), but by His own divine power. The entrance into heaven was accomplished, of course, also by the supernatural power of His glorified soul, which He possessed as a result of the hypostatic union.

Soteriology

The Ascension can be a cause of our salvation in two ways. By placing human nature in heaven, Christ is the cause of the growth of our faith and hope that we too may one day be there. Secondly, Christ, by ascending into heaven, prepares a place for us there. The Ascension is not, of course, a cause of our salvation in the sense of a meritorious cause, but only in the sense of an efficient cause. For the meritorious cause is the Lord's Passion itself, and the Ascension is the cause of our entrance into heaven in this way: by beginning it in Christ—the Head of humanity—it draws after it the members who are united with that Head. These members are all justified people, that is, those who remain in the state of sanctifying grace.

Men of Galilee, why do you stand looking up toward heaven? Alleluia. As you have seen Him going up to heaven, so will He come, alleluia, alleluia, alleluia.

Literature: Fr. M. Sieniatycki, Outline of Catholic Dogmatics

What is theological faith ?

Although the concept of faith is one of the central elements in Christianity, and in religion in general, there is often great confusion and misunderstanding among many people regarding the issue of faith. Yet faith is the necessary beginning of the path to salvation, the first step in turning toward God. So what is this faith that forms the root of our justification?

Faith in general

Let us begin with the concept of faith understood generally, as a concept that can be used not necessarily in a religious context. Faith in general is the firm acceptance of some statement as true based on someone’s testimony. Therefore, faith differs from a hypothesis or opinion, which are not firm acceptances but merely conjectures.

Faith also differs from ordinary knowledge, which is likewise a firm acceptance of something as true, but one acquired through investigation and the discernment of a truth evident to reason.

Theological faith - the divine virtue

The divine virtue of faith is a kind of faith, since it too consists in accepting specific statements (dogmas - revealed truths of faith) as true on account of someone’s testimony. This faith is divine because the testimony on which it is based is divine - God Himself is the source of Revelation containing the dogmas given for belief, which we accept as absolutely true. Christian faith is furthermore supernatural, since we arrive at the act of faith with the help of supernatural grace, not through natural striving alone.

The authority of God - the source of absolute certainty

Since faith is the firm acceptance of something as true, its characteristic feature is certainty. Faith is not a supposition that something might be true, but a strong conviction of truth. Christian faith is not, after all, the result of our personal reflections, but the effect of the fact that God Himself - the most perfect Being - has revealed specific truths to us, and God can neither lie nor err.

Doubts in faith

Since faith is based on God’s testimony, it excludes voluntary doubting but does not exclude involuntary doubts. Because faith consists in accepting truths that are largely not naturally accessible to reason nor obvious to it, involuntary doubts may arise in the believing person. Such doubts may arise as a result of temptations, but they may also be the effect of traits stemming from the personality of a specific individual, their psyche, especially their emotionality. They do not then signify a lack of faith. However, it must be remembered that divine faith excludes voluntary (rational) doubts, since God’s authority surpasses all human authority and possesses the greatest, absolute guarantee of truth.

Definition of faith

Theological faith can thus be defined as the firm, supernatural acceptance as true of all that God has revealed, on account of the reliability of God Himself revealing it. Christian faith requires absolute adherence to all Christian dogmas. In this way, our obedience to God is expressed, our recognition of Him as the highest authority, and our response to the grace from His side, which constitutes our first step toward Him and toward our salvation.

Literature: Fr. M. Sieniatycki, Outline of Catholic Dogmatics

#faith

St. Thomas Aquinas on whether we may reprove our superiors

Fraternal correction, as an act of love, is incumbent upon everyone in relation to any person whom one has a duty to love, if one finds in that person something that needs to be corrected by admonition... However, since a virtuous act should be moderated by due circumstances, when admonishing superiors, subordinates should do so in a fitting manner, and thus not boldly and rudely, but courteously and respectfully... It must be known that in the case of a threat to the faith, subordinates should admonish superiors even publicly.

And thus even Paul, who was subordinate to Peter, rebuked him publicly, and the reason for this was the threatening disturbance in matters of faith.

And this is how the Gloss of Augustine on the letter to the Galatians (2:14) understands it, saying: “Peter himself gave an example to superiors, that in the case of straying from the straight path they should not take offense at the admonitions of subordinates.”

Summa Theologica, II-II, q. 33 a. 4: Whether we are bound to reprove our prelate?

#obedience #correction

Marriage is a natural institution

The concept of "natural" does not mean - "from nature." It means "proper to man." Man is not defined by what he shares with the animal world, but by what distinguishes him from it. This is, after all, the general logical principle that allows us to differentiate between various objects and entities. It is a certain primer. Natural, that is, inscribed in human nature. Man: a purposeful being, superior to animals thanks to his particular abilities, capable of achieving his optimal development in and through community.

(We do not recognize natural law by the fact that a given phenomenon occurs in nature. If that were the case, we would have to deem, for example, a wife devouring her husband as consistent with natural law, following the example of mantises. Natural law (ius naturale) is a philosophical and legal concept referring to universal moral norms derived from reason or the order of creation, rather than from biological empiricism. Therefore, homosexuality is and will remain a deviation inconsistent with natural law, and marriage is by nature indissoluble.)

Marriage is earlier than the state. It's the foundation of society. State authority can only protect it, but has no right to change it. This is an obvious truth, but apparently worth repeating: Marriage has a mixed character. An important public law factor arises from the public interest in recognizing and promoting, through legally established institutions, naturally occurring social structures, including the permanence of marriage. Its breakdown is a violation of the social order, carrying consequences whose burden will be borne by the entire community. And the nullification of the investments that the entire community has made in the form of concessions and privileges granted to spouses and given to the family. What morality calls the evil of divorce has its very concrete and measurable social cost. Financial, ethical, and also in the realm of social trust capital.

“on the one hand, numerous initiatives for the good of the family should be supported, which Christians promote together with other people of good will (for example, wedding anniversary celebrations), while on the other hand, the risk of permissiveness in fundamental questions concerning the essence of marriage and the family must be avoided (cf. John Paul II, January 28, 2002, Letter to Families, 17).

"...Among such endeavors, initiatives that contribute to the public recognition of the indissolubility of marriage through civil legislation must not be lacking (cf. ibid., 17). A firm opposition to any legal and administrative measures that introduce divorce or equate free unions—even homosexual ones—with marriage should be accompanied by constructive attitudes, expressed in proposing legal solutions aimed at improving the social recognition of true marriage within legislation that unfortunately allows divorce.”

#marriage